a little while ago i brought the latest dido album.. Now I have almost 3,000 cd’s and we put all of them onto our MP3 jukebox; basically a custom built PC with dual 180gig drives and itunes, hooked up to the TV..
I use this to sync with my 20gig Ipod and 10gig Ipod.. a perfect solution..
however. BMG music have taken it on themselves to choose how, when, and where I can listen to CD’s that a I legally buy..
if you brought the Dido album (amongst others) before christmas you’d have found it had the CD-AUDIO logo on it… its important to keep this in mind.. the CD-ADUIO logo means the CD is a 100% redbook audio CD, licenced from phillips.
Putting the CD into my PC installed some nasty audio player (without actually asking me!), the first problem is that the CD will ONLY play on a PC through this audio application. the second problem is that this audio application ‘pings’ BMG, now what it tells BMG I’m not sure… I’m still waiting for BMG to tell me what information is collected and sent back to BMG from my machine.
the main thing I was annoyed about was what although I own the CD, BMG choose what I can listen to it on. They didnt seem to understand my main ‘HI-FI’ was a PC…
Putting it into a Apple Mac crashed the Mac completely.. nice move guys…
The bottom line here is that although I own the CD, I cannot listen to it on anything except a ‘real’ hifi, and I cannot move the CD onto my Ipod to listen to..
BMG use a system called CACTUS 2.0 by MIDBAR. I spoke to a few people at BMG and explained that Really I wouldn’t be pirating the CD given that I buy ALL my cd’s, and that I felt ‘cheated’ that they seem to think they can choose where and when I can listen to the CD..
BMG explained that I could download the CD digitally from their website after paying for it (meaning I’ve now paid twice to listen to it!!) but only in WMA (windows media format).. hey the world doesnt revolve around Microsoft guys… i dont use WMA on my Ipod!!
The new version of the Cactus protection does allow you to make digital copies of the CD.. however the quality is crippled at less than 160k (a less than perfect copy) again not really a perfect solution..
I am still waiting for my call from MIDBAR that I was promised by BMG to explain the situation. My promise to them to return ALL my BMG cd’s and albums and charge them an admin fee for doing so is looking more and more interesting…
BMG have now also removed all the CD-AUDIO logos, since they are not licenced to since the CD’s are not 100% redbook CD’s. I advised Phillips about this and they asked BMG to remove the Logos from their CD’s
I’d advise you to be aware that ALL BMG and its partners use the CACTUS protection, basically any cd’s with the following logo on them;

I picked up a copy of the Outkast Cd today.. saw the BMG ‘nasty protection’ logo and put it back on the shelf.. Sorry BMG but you’ve lost me as a customer.. give me one reason why I should spend money on your CD’s..
Of course, every protection system and encryption system is breakable (believe me I’ve broken lots in my career..) so you can get round this protection by reading this
I’ve been asked by BMG to beta test CACTUS 3.0.. probably something I wont do.. I have no interest in helping BMG work out their own problems…